DON'T Build Your Lineup Before Watching This: MLB The Show 26 Outfielders Tier List Revealed!
Category: MLB The Show 26 Posted: May 11, 2026 Views: 19
With the release of MLB The Show 26, outfield player ratings have undergone new changes.
Today, I'm bringing you a brand-new tier list of outfield players, covering dozens of active outfielders, ranging from S-tier to C-tier. This list contains some subjective elements and is for reference only.
Hopefully, this ranking will help you better build your team or find your next goal. Below is the complete ranking.
S-Tier
The main outfielders rated S-tier in MLB The Show 26 are:
- 1. Albert Pujols
- 2. Ian Happ
- 3. Mickey Mantle
- 4. Mike Trout
- 5. Carlos Beltran
Albert Pujols
Among S-tier players in MLB The Show 26, Albert Pujols is arguably the most consistent mainstay - his batting face is textbook accurate, making him suitable for both left and right outfield - hence, he is highly praised by almost all online player reviews. His Speed is around 70, Reaction around 80, and Arm Strength around 80. While not a top-tier defender, he's very solid.
Ian Happ
You might be surprised to see Ian Happ ranked S, but this all-around player has the ability to achieve that. He's a true jack-of-all-trades, capable of playing multiple positions, and he won't falter no matter where you put him.
Mickey Mantle
Mickey Mantle has an amazing reputation as a powerful center fielder. His speed is incredibly high at 94, and his Arm Strength is overwhelmingly good. While his Swing isn't the best in the world, it's certainly not a liability, making him a true all-around player.
Mike Trout
Mike Trout is widely considered the strongest active world-class baseball player in the world, and he's one of the most coveted ultimate cards in MLB The Show 26. This card is currently the strongest outfielder, but his defensive weaknesses are amplified in center field, so you're best suited to placing him in either left or right field.
If you want this top-tier outfielder, you'll need to spend a lot of Stubs. If you lack Stubs, you can directly buy MLB The Show 26 Stubs from IGGM; we offer the fairest prices and fastest service.
Carlos Beltran
Carlos Beltran's speed makes him almost impossible for opponents to bypass in MLB The Show 26, making him a truly deserving S-tier outfielder. His only weakness is his right-handed pitching power of only 68, which slightly diminishes his hitting ability. However, you can obtain this S-tier player for free by completing in-game missions, so what more can we ask for?
A-Tier
A-tier players in MLB The Show 26 are typically players who are very strong in one area but have certain weaknesses. They include:
- 1. Kris Bryant
- 2. Cody Bellinger
- 3. Christian Yelich
- 4. Bryan Reynolds
- 5. Ken Griffey Jr.
Kris Bryant
Kris Bryant is considered by many players to be the epitome of a "golden balanced outfielder" - his swing is smooth and silky, and his passes are reassuring. However, his reaction time is occasionally slow, so it's not recommended to place him in center field, but he can be placed in the corner.
Cody Bellinger
Cody Bellinger was previously a candidate for S-tier in MLB. In MLB The Show 26, although he was relegated to A-tier due to a decline in speed, he remains a representative of offensive outfielders.
Christian Yelich
Christian Yelich's batting statistics are undeniable, but not every player likes his feel and hidden stats. Those who love him adore him, while those who dislike him hate him.
Bryan Reynolds
Bryan Reynolds is rated A-tier primarily because he is the only A-tier outfielder in MLB The Show 26 who can play both left and right field. Although his stats aren't as outstanding as other outfielders, his versatility is his biggest advantage.
Ken Griffey Jr.
This player is highly controversial: his speed is only around 75, he's not particularly good at defense, but his swing is excellent. Most importantly, his price is incredibly high; you'd need to spend around $250,000 MLB The Show 26 Stubs to acquire him. Therefore, he's classified as A-level player.
B and C-level players
MLB The Show 26's B and C-level players are playable, but either have obvious flaws or require specific conditions to perform well. Therefore, only a brief list is provided here:
- 1. Mookie Betts
- 2. Don Baylor
- 3. Mickey Moniak
- 4. Aaron Judge
- 5. Curtis Granderson
Mookie Betts
Mookie Betts has decent hitting ability, but his defensive stats are laughable: slow speed, sluggish jump, and poor passing power. However, if you like his hitting, you can still use him.
Don Baylor
Don Baylor has good speed, balanced hitting stats against both left and right pitchers, and his defense isn't the worst, making him a versatile player.
Mickey Moniak
Mickey Moniak's stats are good except for his 75-78 batting average against left-handed pitchers. Most importantly, his card is free to obtain.
Aaron Judge
Aaron Judge's strength is his power hitting ability, but his batting average in MLB The Show 26 is low. In other words, while he has great power, his ability to hit is questionable.
Curtis Granderson
Curtis Granderson is very strong against right-handed pitchers, but becomes easy prey against left-handed pitchers. Therefore, you can only place him in a fixed position.
The above is a ranking of the outfielders in MLB The Show 26. The rankings within the same tier are not in any particular order. Again, this ranking has some subjective factors and is for reference only. Hope this helps.
Recommended Article
-
MLB The Show 26 Weekend Classic 2 Pitcher Tier List | Why Randy Johnson Reigns Supreme?
-
MLB The Show 26 Bobby Witt Jr. Takeover Program Guide | How to Easily Complete the Chain of Missions?
-
MLB The Show 26 April Spotlight Drop 5 is the program you must complete to unlock Chipper Jones and Ben Rice!
-
MLB The Show 26 April Spotlight Speedrun Guide | 0 Stubs to Get Elly De La Cruz
-
MLB The Show 26 Cityscapes Program Guide | How to complete Collection Missions?
-
Try this Diamond Quest Loop in MLB The Show 26 to earn 40k Stubs per hour! Forget WBC Mini Season!












