Language & Currency

Language

English

English

Deutsch

Français

Español

Italiano

Netherlands

Português

عربى

Display Currency

$ USD

$ USD

€ EUR

£ GBP

A$ AUD

C$ CAD

N.Kr. NOK

S.Kr. SEK

D.Kr. DKK

I.Kr. ISK

CLP CLP

COP COP

S/. PEN

ARS ARS

zł PLN

S.R. SAR

﷼ QAR

AED AED

Sign Up
  • Verification Code
I want to get information about activities, sales and personal offers

or continue with social networks

twitch google steam reddit discord
Already have an account?
Log In
Remember me Forgot your password?

or continue with social networks

twitch google steam reddit discord
Not a member? Sign up now

Is MLB The Show 26 the worst in the series? Players want changes but the developers are slacking off

Category: MLB The Show 26 Posted: Jun 24, 2026 Views: 15

If you're a fan of MLB The Show series, your feelings are likely conflicted: you want it to improve, yet you fear that if it attracts a massive player base, the developers will turn it into a blatant cash grab.

Unfortunately, it seems MLB The Show 26 has become that unfortunate culprit. While 25 and 24 certainly had their own issues, MLB 26 appears to be a culmination of so many shortcomings that many players on forums are labeling it the worst entry to date.

Given the franchise's monopoly on the genre, you'd likely prefer the developers to address these issues quickly rather than switching to other baseball games. The awkward reality, however, judging by recent developments, is that the developers seem completely indifferent.

With a new WBC took place this year, one would expect players to pay closer attention to MLB 26, and for the developers to be more motivated to create a high-quality, player-friendly title.

Yet, more than three months after launch, the game's reception is worse than that of EA Sports FC 26, a title frequently mocked for its greedy monetization practices.

In a summer dominated by FIFA World Cup discussions, we're taking a moment to focus on virtual baseball. From a grounded, no-nonsense player perspective, let's discuss exactly what went wrong with MLB The Show 26.

Is MLB The Show 26 the worst in the series? Players want changes but the developers are slacking off

20-card cap ruined everything

Back when MLB 26 first launched, some players presciently warned that the new 20-card cap on the trading market would eventually ruin everything. While there was some pushback at the time, look at the situation now, hardly anyone has a good word to say about this mechanic.

This is because the baffling cap severely stifles one of the most effective ways for casual players to farm MLB 26 stubs, all while the developers claim the move was intended to curb market inflation.

You don't even need us to spell it out; just open MLB 26 and you'll see the market is still a mess, with top-tier players still needing hundreds of thousands or even millions of stubs. 20-card cap feels like a misguided solo act by the developers, a solution that solved nothing.

If you're an unwealthy MLB The Show 26 player, you used to be able to farm the stubs needed for high-tier cards by stacking and selling common cards. Now, however, a 20-card cap has cut off that avenue, effectively making consuming real cash the only viable solution.

We acknowledge that the game's survival depends on microtransactions, but that doesn't mean they should be elevated above all else, especially not while hiding behind the sanctimonious claim that it's for the players' own good.

Using bug fixes as a pretext to screw over players

With card investment and trading no longer effective, Mini Seasons became the go-to spot for farming stubs and packs. But lo-and-behold, even this chill mode has been ruined in MLB The Show 26.

Recently, Mini Seasons has been plagued by bugs that cause progress to roll back for no reason. You could grind through a dozen games and be on the verge of the playoffs, only to finish a match and find your progress reset all the way back to Game 1.

What's even more absurd is that the issue remains unfixed. In a game available on the latest generation of consoles, your only solution is to manually reset the mode yourself!

It's no wonder people joke that a random player from the forums would do a better job fixing bugs than the actual technical team. While it's just a joke, at least other players actually understand what the community needs.

It's not that MLB The Show 26 never fixes bugs; there was previously a glitch in WBC Mini Seasons mode that allowed players to claim Championship bundles infinitely.

And guess what? When faced with a bug that actually benefited players, the developers moved with lightning speed, pushing out a stealth hotfix overnight.

Hotfixing bugs is fine in principle, unlimited rewards essentially ruin the game's economy, but after applying the fix, players were horrified to discover that AI ​​for CPU pitchers had been altered as well.

This meant that regardless of the difficulty setting, pitches would consistently hug the very outer edge of the strike zone, pointlessly dragging out every single-player game by ten to fifteen minutes.

Honestly, it's hard not to suspect that the developers simply couldn't stand players acquiring packs too quickly, so they used the bug fix as an excuse to intentionally make farming bundles harder.

Frankly, that kind of behavior is even more disheartening than sheer negligence.

Uninspired and superficial updates

It seems like MLB 26 has been rolling out new programs every week since launch, alongside longer-running major programs. But if you've been actively playing, you know the gameplay is largely the same, it's just the same old routine repackaged in different wrapping.

From early events like Cityscapes and Mural to the recently launched Summer Series, completing these programs does yield new rewards, but the core gameplay loops are just recycled variations of the same few mechanics. You'd think an AI could generate a more creative task list than the developers, or maybe they are using AI? Yikes.

Uninformed outsiders might ask, What is there to complain about when there are new events every week? But only those of us who haven't given up on MLB 26 yet realize it's essentially just clocking in for a shift on a virtual baseball diamond.

Since that's the case, why waste time grinding through tedious programs for Stubs when you could enter IGGM MLB 26 Stubs giveaway on Discord? A simple emoji reaction could land you a massive haul of Stubs for free, doesn't that sound like a much better deal?

3,000K MLB 26 stubs free giveaways at IGGM Discord

It's time for MLB 26 to wake up!

Despite all the criticism, our feelings toward MLB 26 stem more from frustration at its wasted potential than pure disappointment.

After all, the virtual baseball experience remains top-tier. And aside from garbage mechanics like 20-card cap, some of this year's new features, like ABS system, are genuinely valuable.

That's precisely why the community has been flooded with lengthy critiques regarding MLB 26's poor performance over the last three months. Player support and patience should be rewarded, not used as an excuse for the development team to slack off.

The only silver lining right now is Summer Developer Livestream scheduled for June 26th. Will this be a turning point for MLB 26, or just another half-hearted appearance by the developers? Let's wait and see.

Surplus stock:
Connecting to online customer service, please wait.

.