MLB The Show 26 Only New Threads Cards Worth Your Time | From an unstoppable closer to a disappointing collection reward
Category: MLB The Show 26 Posted: Mar 27, 2026 Views: 23
New Threads series cards for MLB The Show 26 have been released, and these players who have moved to new teams will be the focus of Diamond Dynasty in the coming days.
Acquiring these players isn't particularly difficult - you can obtain all of them for around one hundred thousand stubs. But as you know, some of these cards are stronger than others, and the elite ones are better suited for your squad. Let's go from strongest to weakest and see which ones are worth your consideration.

Pitchers
87 OVR Ryan Helsley, Orioles | CP
Ryan Helsley is without a doubt the top card in this collection, and he's a strong recommendation for your bullpen. In the current game, elite right-handed relief pitchers are relatively scarce, and Helsley stands out as one of the best. He comes with Outlier II, and pairing his high-velocity cutter with a slider makes him essentially Rich Gossage from MLB 25. While he also has a curveball, it's best not to rely on it too heavily.
87 OVR Robert Suarez, Braves | RP
Robert Suarez can be viewed as a slightly toned-down version of Ryan Helsley. He adds a sinker to his arsenal, which might give him a slight edge against right-handed hitters.
88 OVR Ranger Suárez, Red Sox | SP
Ranger Suárez is no easy opponent. All of his pitches come in with below-average velocity and feature significant movement, and the slower speed adds an extra layer of deception, making him tough to hit. However, when facing high-level players in Ranked mode, his effectiveness drops considerably.
88 OVR Sonny Gray, Red Sox | SP
Gray's card features a pair of curveballs, and his delivery remains somewhat unconventional. Still, his overall performance is fairly average, with few standout qualities. His H/9 stats are underwhelming (81 vs. lefties, 63 vs. righties), and his Control is merely okay. As a typical cutter-sinker pitcher with two curveballs, he doesn't pose a major threat in high-level matchups.
87 OVR Edward Cabrera, Cubs |SP
Edward Cabrera's profile is similar to that of another Chicago Cubs right-hander, Jake Arrieta - his game centers on a hard sinker. His circle change comes in at 88, but in actual gameplay, that's not quite fast enough to place him among the top-tier pitchers.
Hitters and Fielders
91 OVR Kyle Tucker, Dodgers | RF
Kyle Tucker is the highest-rated card in this collection. He comes with some wonderful Quirks such as First-Pitch Hitter and Dead Red. In terms of hitting attributes, aside from power, his stats range between 85 and 90.
90 OVR Pete Alonso, Orioles | 1B
Pete Alonso is a right-handed first baseman with decent stats. His 97 power and 72 contact resemble those of 87 OVR Travis Hafner, but Pete has better Contact and Clutch ratings. However, his swing doesn't feel as smooth as last year's, and his 31 Speed is very low.
Still, he currently ranks as the best right-handed first baseman aside from 99 OVR Albert Pujols. Thanks to this year's Parallel Mod system, you can easily boost his defense into the 70s and his speed into the 60s or even low 70s, freeing him from his previous role as a one-dimensional hitter and making him more effective than before.
88 OVR Marcus Semien, Mets | 2B
Marcus Semien is a pure right-handed second baseman. He's on par with Gleyber Torres but offers better defense. Torres has a slightly smoother swing, while Semien can still hit home runs against right-handed pitching. For players working with a limited budget, Marcus Semien is a very solid choice.
90 OVR Jorge Polanco, Mets | 1B (2B, 3B)
Jorge Polanco is a switch hitter with stats that include 71 Contact vs. righties, 97 Contact vs. lefties, 85 and 76 power, and 108 Clutch. His defense is poor, his speed isn't great, and he has a smaller frame. In MLB 26, first-base defense has become more important, as taller, longer-limbed players can prevent more hits.
Although he's quite popular right now, in terms of value, a similarly performing card like Carlos Santana is currently going for around 20,000 stubs, while Jorge Polanco commands as much as 70,000 stubs due to his hype. If you're looking to be more economical with your MLB 26 stubs, there's no need to go after this card right away.
91 OVR Bo Bichette, Mets | 3B (2B, SS)
As the collection reward, his stats show 101/100/110 in Contact and Clutch, but his power sits at just 70 against righties and 82 against lefties. Bo Bichette is a very poor defender and lacks speed. His role likely fits as a powerful pinch hitter against left-handers in your top-tier lineup. If you enjoyed the feel of his Moonshot card from last year, this one might suit you well.
You'll notice that several New Threads cards weren't mentioned. That's because they either lack standout qualities or come with fatal flaws. You might use them in casual play, but in Ranked mode, their weaknesses become magnified. The cards highlighted above represent the most valuable ones from MLB The Show 26's New Threads collection. Keep in mind that some of these cards can't be acquired through the marketplace - you'll need to complete specific objectives to earn them.
Recommended Article
-
MLB The Show 26 New Threads Program Guide | How to land a 90 OVR Alonso without spending a dime?
-
MLB The Show 26 Parallel Mods System | Not just adds 5 to All-Around Stats! The secret to further enhancing your players!
-
MLB The Show 26 Review: Game-Changer or Just a Roster Update? | Still the Best Baseball Game, but far from praiseworthy
-
MLB the Show 26 Road to the Show Overhauls the Draft | How to pick the best university for your Pro Career?
-
Don't worry about missing MLB the Show 26 Early Access! Here is the guide to complete 1st Inning Program before time runs out
-
MLB the Show 26 Secret Pitching Attributes you need to boost to dominate all the Core Modes!














