MLB The Show 26 Egg Hunt Event Is Easier Than You Think | The lazy player's guide to a full set of rewards
Category: MLB The Show 26 Posted: Apr 07, 2026 Views: 25
After April Fools' Day, Easter follows closely, and MLB The Show 26 returns with its Egg Hunt event. Many players enjoy this event because it's more fun compared to the usual ones.
The core of Egg Hunt Program is collecting eggs of different colors. Each egg corresponds to a specific set of missions, and completing them earns progress points. The event includes both regular eggs and Mystery Missions, with the latter being slightly more challenging. However, you don't need to complete all of them to claim the final grand reward.

Egg Hunt Program Reward
- 10 Points: 87 OVR Egg Hunt Series Tyler Rogers
- 20 Points: Icon
- 30 Points: 88 OVR Egg Hunt Series Phil Rizzuto
- 40 Points: Icon
- 50 Points: 89 OVR Egg Hunt Series Jason Varitek
- 60 Points: MLB The Show 26 pack (x5)
- 70 Points: 2,500 XP
- 80 Points: Golden Egg Icon
- 90 Points: Deluxe Candy Basket pack
- 100 Points: 89 OVR Egg Hunt Series Jackson Merrill and 5,000 XP
Besides the eggs, the developers have provided many other ways to earn points, so you can simply pick the easier tasks to complete first. Below are the ways you can gain points:
- 4 Moments (two worth 3 points each, two worth 2 points each)
- 10 Mystery Missions (5 points each)
- Completing the collection of five colored eggs (10 points each)
- Collecting both Red and Green eggs (10 points each)
Mystery Missions
Mystery Missions are the trickiest part of this event. You can choose the five easier ones to finish, and rely on the eggs for the remaining points.
Wait a Third
This mission requires you to win a game in any mode using Gold card of Clay Holmes. Just go to Team Affinity system, find New York Yankees' starting Gold player – that's Clay Holmes. Simply complete two Moments challenges for Yankees to earn 20,000 Affinity points and unlock him.
Customizable Mini Seasons Length
This mission only needs you to earn 500 PXP with players wearing jersey number 7 or 28. In Mini Seasons mode, use players like Joe Mauer (#7) or Nolan Arenado (#28) to accumulate PXP.
Conq Mysterymaxxing
This mission requires you to hit an extra-base hit (double, triple, or home run) with Troy Tulowitzki in Conquest mode. If you've already finished Starter Program, you'll receive a Gold Troy Tulowitzki card. His stats aren't outstanding, but his swing feels excellent. Slot him into your Conquest lineup, play a game, and hit a home run or a double.
I'm Blue
This mission requires you to win a game in any mode using Kerry Wood. Kerry Wood has both a Common and a Diamond version – either works. Right at the beginning of Common Courtesy Program, you'll get a 64-OVR Common Kerry Wood. Just complete two Moments challenges in that program – it's very easy.
KYLE TEST
These missions ask you to hit a home run with Kyle Schwarber or Kyle Stowers in Diamond Dynasty. Testing shows that other players named Kyle (e.g., Kyle Higashioka) do not work. Simply put the required player in the leadoff spot or anywhere in the lineup, go into Mini Boss Showdown in Diamond Dynasty or directly play a Stadium Challenge. Choose Rookie difficulty, hit a home run, and then exit the mission to complete it.
Whoops, he's not supposed to be there (A. J. Puk)
This mission requires you to pitch one inning with A. J. Puk in any mode. A. J. Puk is a Free Agent card whose value has risen from 300 to 1,400 MLB Ther Show 26 stubs. You can safely skip this mission.
Back (4 missions)
The next four "Back" missions require you to hit extra-base hits with specific players:
- Back: Nolan Arenado (D-Backs)
- Back-to-Back: Nolan Gorman (Cardinals)
- Back-to-Back-to-Back: Juan Yepez (Free Agents)
- Back-to-Back-to-Back-to-Back: Dylan Carlson (Cubs)
You don't have to complete all four, because some players are harder to acquire. You can just use Nolan Arenado and Nolan Gorman, whose cards are easier to get.
Eggs
Orange Egg
On the main screen, in Moments section, you'll see an orange egg icon right in the center. Simply complete at least four Moments challenges in order to obtain the orange egg.
This is a routine task that appears every year and is very easy. After finishing the challenges, you not only completely the orange egg but also earn an additional 10 points as a mission reward.
Green Egg
In any multiplayer mode, accumulate a total of 10 doubles. You can make this easier by choosing a weaker opponent or playing against a friend.
Red Egg
This egg requires you to complete 3 stolen bases in any multiplayer mode. Stealing bases is relatively easy in this game – just pick players with good speed and stealing ability.
Yellow Egg
This egg requires you to capture all Strongholds on the map in Conquest mode.
Blue Egg
This egg requires you to capture every single tile on the map in Conquest mode. As long as you patiently finish the entire Conquest map, both the yellow and blue eggs are almost guaranteed.
Pink Egg and Purple Egg
The pink and purple eggs require you to complete the corresponding challenges in Diamond Dynasty. Compared to previous Egg Hunt, these tasks are simpler for newcomers this time. It's recommended to play on Rookie difficulty.
First complete a few Moments and the small challenges along the way, then enter Stadium Challenge. With steady play, you can win almost 100% of the time. Both eggs can be obtained in a single Diamond Dynasty run.
Egg Hunt event in MLB 26 is generally on the easier side. The eggs themselves are not hard to get – the real challenge lies in Mystery Missions. This year, you only need five eggs to complete the event, lowering the barrier, so you can easily claim all the rewards.
Recommended Article
-
MLB The Show 26 April Spotlight gives free player cards and flexible missions
-
MLB The Show 26 April Fool's Day Common Courtesy Program Guide | How to get 64 OVR Player Cards, Stubs, and other Rewards?
-
MLB The Show 26 Top 10 Stadiums Ranked | Which one will you unlock to gain a competitive edge?
-
MLB The Show 26 Online Pitching Guide | How to break batters' timing by Pinpoint Pitching?
-
MLB 26 Stubs Free Giveaways
-
MLB The Show 26 Ultimate Conquest Mode Guide | How to stockpile stubs and packs without spending a dime?
















