MLB The Show 26 Top 10 Pitchers Are Heating up in May | Your stubs are safe if you pick these Aces
Category: MLB The Show 26 Posted: May 28, 2026 Views: 15
In June, MLB teams will begin their trade period. Since player performances tend to stabilize in May, teams will refer to May data for their trades. These changes will also be reflected in MLB The Show 26.
Let's focus on the top 10 pitchers of May, examine their stats in MLB The Show 26, and predict how those stats might change.

Here are top 10 pitchers of May:
- No.1 80 OVR Jacob Misiorowski
- No.2 85 OVR Cristopher Sánchez
- No.3 81 OVR Cam Schlittler
- No.4 94 OVR Shohei Ohtani
- No.5 90 OVR Paul Skenes
- No.6 85 OVR Hunter Greene
- No.7 88 OVR Chris Sale
- No.8 78 OVR Aaron Ashby
- No.9 78 OVR Braxton Ashcraft
- No.10 72 OVR Kyle Harrison
No.1 80 OVR Jacob Misiorowski (SP, Brewers)
Jacob Misiorowski's Live Card in MLB The Show 26 is only 80 OVR, but his form in May was unprecedentedly hot. Throughout the month, he recorded 49 strikeouts while issuing just 6 walks. Thanks to his outstanding performance, he became the first pitcher in the 2026 season to reach 100 strikeouts.
In a game against Cardinals, he astonishingly threw 57 pitches exceeding 100 mph, setting a single-game record for the majors since tracking of this statistic began in 2008. Before his game against Cardinals on May 25, he had thrown 29.1 consecutive scoreless innings.
If he can maintain his hot form, his OVR might increase by 5 points, turning him into a Diamond Card. He is currently worth about 800 MLB The Show 26 stubs, and investing in him will almost certainly yield you stubs.
No.2 85 OVR Cristopher Sánchez (SP, Phillies)
Sánchez's most remarkable achievement this month came on May 27, when he set a new franchise record with 44.2 consecutive scoreless innings, breaking the record previously held by Hall of Famer Grover Cleveland Alexander, which had stood since 1911.
This astonishing record is just 14.1 innings shy of the all-time record of 59 innings set by Orel Hershiser in 1988. In MLB The Show 26, his H/9 Right is only 56, which is undoubtedly a weakness. However, given his performance since May, this flaw may be addressed in the next update.
No.3 81 OVR Cam Schlittler (SP, Yankees)
Throughout May, Schlittler allowed 1 run or fewer in 7 of his 8 starts, showing remarkable consistency. As of May 10, he became the first pitcher since Hall of Famer Walter Johnson in 1913 to record 50+ strikeouts, fewer than 10 walks, and no more than 1 home run allowed over his first 9 starts of the season.
Although his performance is not as flashy as Jacob Misiorowski's, maintaining such a high level of consistency fully demonstrates his quality as a top-tier pitcher. Moreover, the official developers have placed a 93 OVR Cam Schlittler card in Rivalry Weekend Recap Program, which is worth collecting.
No.4 94 OVR Shohei Ohtani (SP, Dodgers)
Shohei Ohtani's overall performance could rank in the top three. However, Dodgers avoided overloading him to prevent excessive strain, so he did not pitch excessively.
Even so, he displayed astonishing consistency, with an extremely low opponent batting average, and almost no one could hit a home run against him at home. His card in MLB The Show 26 is already among the best, so his overall rating may not be increased further, but his stats could still be boosted.
No.5 90 OVR Paul Skenes (SP, Pirates)
In May, Skenes posted a 3-1 record overall, with 45 strikeouts against only 4 walks, and 16 scoreless innings.
After a strong performance of 6 scoreless innings on May 17th, Skenes became the first pitcher this season to reach 200 strikeouts. However, he is not underrated in MLB 26, so he is not expected to be adjusted, similar to Shohei Ohtani.
No.6 85 OVR Hunter Greene (SP, Reds)
After a two-week absence due to injury, Hunter Greene returned to the pitching table on May 5th with a scoreless 6-inning performance. To ensure a healthy return, Greene participated in a series of minor league rehabilitation games, striking out 24 in 13 innings, maintaining his dominant fastball.
While still not quite on par with top pitchers like Paul Skenes, Hunter Greene's breakout performance in May may earn him a rating increase.
No.7 88 OVR Chris Sale (SP, Braves)
As a veteran and nine-time All-Star, Chris Sale performed very consistently, allowing only 3 earned runs over 4 consecutive starts while recording 33 strikeouts. In a game against Rockies on May 2, he threw 6 scoreless innings, giving up just 1 hit and striking out 9. Among veterans, this level of performance can be considered the very best.
No.8 78 OVR Aaron Ashby (RP, Brewers)
Aaron Ashby mostly pitched in relief during May, yet he ranked first in Wins Above Replacement. He is a highly underrated pitcher and will almost certainly receive a rating upgrade in MLB The Show 26.
No.9 78 OVR Braxton Ashcraft (SP, Pirates)
Braxton Ashcraft is a steady starting pitcher who consistently delivers quality starts. His form peaked in May, and he also possesses excellent control. He remained undefeated throughout May, with an overall outstanding performance.
No.10 72 OVR Kyle Harrison (SP, Brewers)
In May, Kyle Harrison posted a 4-0 record. He managed to keep winning games, control runs perfectly, and even set a franchise record. Although there is still a gap compared to top pitchers, there is no doubt that Kyle Harrison was in very good form throughout May.
All 10 pitchers performed quite well in May. Some of them may attract attention from other teams and be traded, and MLB The Show 26 might also release new cards for them. If you want to invest to earn Stubs, most players on this list are good options.
Recommended Article
-
MLB The Show 26 is making the way harder to earn Program XP: Why does this game seem to be in maintenance mode?
-
Earn 30k+ Stubs per hour with Insane Silver to Gold Exchange Glitch after MLB The Show 26 Roster Update!
-
MLB The Show 26 May All-Position Hitter Rankings | The free reward that outplays collection legends
-
MLB The Show 26 May Spotlight Drop 3 Program Guide | The free rewards you'd be absolutely crazy to skip
-
MLB The Show 26 Rivalry Weekend Recap Program Guide | Skip the hardest challenges and still maximize your rewards!
-
MLB The Show 26 Two-Month Review | The Split Reality of Market Collapse and Gameplay Evolution















