MLB The Show 26 Jackie Robinson Day Players Tier List | A few low‑overall surprises outshine the rest
Category: MLB The Show 26 Posted: Apr 17, 2026 Views: 12
This year's Jackie Robinson Day in MLB The Show 26 brings an unprecedented wave of new content, including multiple Storylines cards, several Rookie of the Year cards, a brand-new Collection Reward, and a number of Pack guys.
Even without using any Stubs to acquire new players, you'll be able to get plenty of free ones. But for Diamond Dynasty, the real question is: do these new cards actually improve your squad? Which ones are worth using? Let's take a closer look.

D Tier
- 88 OVR Luis Gil: A four-pitch pitcher who underperforms. He can just barely handle CPU opponents, but not recommended for use against human players.
- 88 OVR Smokey Joe: Similar to Luis Gil. Good velocity but lacks pitch mix; poor overall utility.
- 88 OVR Dontrelle Willis: Poor control, fastball only 92 mph, and an unimpressive pitch arsenal.
- 89 OVR Bill Foster: Even slower than Dontrelle Willis, with mediocre control.
- 88 OVR Jackie Robinson: A giveaway card. Mediocre power potential, not much value.
- 90 OVR Willie Mays: Hitting stats are average, 86 speed, overall rating propped up mainly by defensive reaction.
Tier C
- 88 OVR Michael Fulmer: Good pitch mix, but poor per-nine stats.
- 88 OVR Leroy Matlock: Most stats on this card are weak, though he has some extra-base ability. Can be used in casual games.
- 88 OVR Ray Dandridge: Solid defense, consistent contact but no power, not suited as a core hitter.
- 89 OVR Toni Stone: A contact-oriented second baseman, but severely lacking in power.
- 89 OVR Judy Johnson: High contact, no power, defense and speed unremarkable. Barely serviceable.
- 89 OVR Monte Irvin: Can play many positions, but neither offense nor defense stands out. Not effective.
- 89 OVR Leon Day: Has five pitches, but overall pitching stats are mediocre.
- 90 OVR Bullet Rogan: Poor per-nine stats, max fastball only 94 mph, pitch metrics average. Contact is decent but power is low.
- 89 OVR Rap Dixon: Swing is okay, but hitting and defensive numbers are unimpressive.
- 90 OVR David Justice: Very strong against lefties, but defense and consistency are too poor for a long-term starter.
Tier B
- 88 OVR Drake Baldwin: This card is mostly average, but players will use him as a full-time starter rather than platooning, so his ability to hit lefties is a plus. Power numbers aren't the worst, but not good enough either.
- 88 OVR Andy Cooper: Andy Cooper has five pitches and a nice mix: 4-seam fastball, slurve, screwball, changeup, and sinker. This allows for some variety on the mound, so overall he's usable.
- 89 OVR Larry Doby: Larry Doby is excellent as a second-base platoon player. He has a good swing and useful quirks. Good stats against righties, but weak against lefties.
- 89 OVR Oscar Charleston: His swing has always been solid. The rest of his stats aren't the worst, he has some power, and his speed is decent.
- 90 OVR Hank Thompson: Overall power and contact are not as good as Oscar Charleston's, but like Charleston, he's a left-handed power-type batter.
- 90 OVR Scott Rolen: His contact and power numbers are decent, but his swing is somewhat poor; otherwise he'd be in A Tier.
Tier A
88 OVR Willard Brown
Low contact, high power, with acceptable speed and defense. Can perform at All-Star or even Hall of Fame difficulty, especially suited for lower-difficulty players.
89 OVR Ryan Howard
Excellent as a pinch hitter off the bench. Very good against righties with great power, but struggles significantly against lefties and in low-Vision situations.
90 OVR Biz Mackey
Biz Mackey is a switch-hitting catcher with elite defensive stats across the board. All his defensive attributes are around 90, with 93 arm strength, making him the best defensive catcher in the current game meta. His hitting stats aren't bad either.
90 OVR Corbin Carroll
Corbin Carroll has maxed-out speed, high contact, and can hit righties. His home-run power is weaker in lefty-on-lefty matchups, but that's not what he's used for.
92 OVR Carlos Beltran
Carlos Beltran is a switch-hitting center fielder. His contact numbers are decent, power is a bit low (63 vs RHP), speed reaches 80, making him better suited for a corner outfield spot.
Tier S
90 OVR Kris Bryant
Kris Bryant has 91/77 contact, but high clutch makes up for it. His power vs both sides is around 80, with excellent defense and reaction, and he can play multiple positions. He has quirks like First-Pitch Hitter, Dead Red, and Breaking Ball Hitter, and with his excellent hitting attributes, he performs well on All-Star or Hall of Fame difficulty.
91 OVR John Donaldson
He doesn't have Outlier Slider or Outlier Fastball, but his 101 mph fastball paired with an 80 mph forkball creates a massive speed differential, making him one of the most effective strikeout pitchers in the current meta.
94 OVR Jackie Robinson
Jackie Robinson is clearly S Tier. His attributes are strong across the board, and after parallel upgrades he reaches 105/106 contact, 81/80 power, combined with speed and defense. He can play second base or even shortstop. He also has two core quirks—Dead Red and Breaking Ball Hitter—that make his swing even more effective. Compared to previous years, this may be one of the best Jackie Robinson cards ever.
This Jackie Robinson Day is the most content-rich in MLB The Show series history. You should prioritize completing Storylines missions to unlock Jackie Robinson Collection Reward card. For players who just want to quickly finish the event program, focus on using the higher-rated Storylines players, while D and C Tier cards can simply serve as filler for missions.
Recommended Article
-
MLB The Show 26 Jackie Robinson Day Program Reward and Collection Guide | Lazy gamer's route to 25 free cards and the final reward
-
MLB The Show 26 Multiplayer Program 2 is live with 500K+ value rewards | How to earn them fast?
-
MLB The Show 26 2nd Inning Program Guide | How to get half a million XP in time?
-
MLB The Show 26 Top 10 Teams Full Ratings and Roster Breakdown | A few of these contenders look completely lost
-
Is MLB The Show 26 First Weekend Classic worth your time? Bernie Williams vs. Victor Martinez
-
MLB The Show 26 Online Mode is being ruined by inflated scores | Is the new PCI hitting meta broken?














